Pastor from Jacksonville gets prison for lying about $600K tax debt

Steve Patterson Jacksonville | Florida Times-Union | Updated May 1, 2026, 1:27 p.m. ET

A prosperous pastor who lied to avoid owing about $600,000 in income tax will serve a nine-month prison sentence, a federal judge in Jacksonville has decided.

“When you get done, you’ll have the rest of your life in front of you to do good,” Senior U.S. District Judge Timothy Corrigan told Brian Carn Jr., the 37-year-old leader of a church that created operations in Jacksonville; Charlotte, N.C. (its headquarters); and Houston, Texas.

Carn pleaded guilty in January to obstructing the Internal Revenue Service’s efforts to collect the tax and his lawyer told Corrigan April 30 that “my client is guilty as sin.”

But defense attorney Walter Reynoso emphasized good deeds Carn had performed as well, from paying off people’s car bills and medical expenses to helping others rebuild their lives.

The people Carn helped included his own family, the judge heard.

“He came to get me out of the street and straightened my life out,” Carn’s father told the judge, recounting his son traveling to Louisiana to reconnect with him.

“I was his daddy and I didn’t raise him,” Brian Carn Sr. said.

Carn, who founded the nondenominational Kingdom City Church in 2016, had been in trouble with the IRS from almost that same point.

A preacher since the age of 12, the Jacksonville native hadn’t received a fixed salary but simply withdrew cash from his ministry for his own use, according to a prosecution sentencing memo. Carn’s accountant used information from the ministry to prepare a tax return in 2016 that listed his 2015 income around $1.4 million and his taxes due at $606,722, according to the memo.

But rather than pay that, Carn forged a back-dated, $120,000-a-year employment contract and hired a different accountant to file an amended return. When the IRS saw through that and tried to collect its money, Carn lied to the agency during a collections process that lasted years and kept the door open for criminal prosecution when he obstructed the government.

“He failed to render to Caesar, that is, the government, that which belongs to the government,” Corrigan said, borrowing from an account used in three Gospels about Jesus' answer to a trick question.

Carn told Corrigan he was facing consequences of his decisions, saying "I take full responsibility."

The minister had told congregants much the same early in 2026. In a livestream preserved on YouTube, Carn told supporters in January he had to own his choices.

“Just because there was no malicious intent in it doesn’t remove accountability,” he said at the time. "… What I mishandled, I still had the responsibility to correct."

Carn's plea agreement in January included a requirement to pay $595,989 in restitution, and Reynoso said the minister arrived at his sentencing ready to make a payment.

U.S. Justice Department attorney Max Willner-Giwerc challenged the idea that Carn had changed his ways, telling the judge the minister had understated his income in other filings as recently as January 2026.

The judge's nine-month sentence was half of what Willner-Giwerc had sought, but Corrigan said he thought it was important that that Carn serve some time behind bars.

At the sentencing, Corrigan agreed to recommend that the federal Bureau of Prisons consider placing Carn in that agency's facility in Jesup, Georgia in as low-security of a setting as possible. He's free until the prison system tells him to report to start his term.

 
 

Publication details

When Your Future Is at Stake, Experience Matters.

Facing criminal charges can be overwhelming. You deserve an experienced legal team that will protect your rights, fight for your freedom, and guide you through every step of the process.

Contact The Law Offices of Walter A. Reynoso, P.A., today to schedule your initial consultation. Hablamos su idioma.